Does the brain generate consciousness? Is human morality the product of brain chemistry?
According to materialist theories, the brain is a machine that produces consciousness. That is, consciousness is thought to arise solely from physical matter, as a product of neuronal activity. However, these theories fail to answer the fundamental question of how consciousness can emerge from purely physical phenomena. They do not explain how a chemical or electrical event in the brain—something inherently non-conscious—becomes conscious. Instead, they simply assert that it happens “somehow” and promise that the mechanism will eventually be revealed, in accordance with the materialist framework. Yet the notion that matter alone can generate consciousness leads to numerous absurdities. It is well known that the human brain consists of bundles of neurons—specialized cells responsible for receiving sensory input from the external world, sending motor commands to muscles, and transmitting electrical signals at every step in between. Neurons can be compared to electrical wires that communicate via neurotransmitters—special chemicals that relay information between brain cells. Impulses travel throughout the body through ion channels, with the movement of sodium and potassium ions across cell membranes driving all neural activity. In this sense, the brain functions as an executive nervous system, performing complex neural tasks, but it is not a legislative system. That is, it is not a source of meaning or morality, and it does not generate consciousness. This has been scientifically demonstrated in numerous experiments since the early twentieth century, including the pioneering work of brain surgeon Wilder Penfield, who operated on conscious patients and revolutionized our understanding of the human brain.
While his patients were fully conscious, though under local anesthesia, Penfield opened their skulls and applied electrical stimulation directly to their brains. Using a scalpel and a small electrode, he was able to explore and map the human brain. Throughout his career, he was driven by the central question that has preoccupied scientists and philosophers for centuries: can the mind—thinking, reasoning, and imagination—be explained solely by the functions of the brain? He developed a surgical technique that became known as the “Montreal Procedure,” in which patients remained awake and able to interact with him. After administering local anesthetics, he removed a portion of the skull to expose the brain tissue of the conscious patient. When he stimulated specific areas of the brain, patients could immediately report what they were experiencing. For example, when he applied a small electrode to the region controlling hand movement, the patient’s hand would move, as the brain sent signals commanding it to do so. It should be remembered that the brain functions as an executive system. Penfield would then ask the patient to prevent the hand from moving while he continued stimulating the same area, yet the patient would be unable to stop the movement. This occurred because muscles respond to the brain’s commands. Thus, when Penfield stimulated the exposed region responsible for hand movement, the hand moved involuntarily, regardless of the patient’s efforts to resist. It may therefore be argued that the brain initiated one action, while the patient, in his conscious awareness, intended another. From this, one may conclude that consciousness and will—non-physical realities—are distinct from the brain, which is a physical organ. In other words, the conscious intention of the patient is one thing, and the corresponding brain activity is another. The essential point is that the human brain governs executive functions, but it is not the source of consciousness, will, or decision-making.Penfield was able to map the functions of tissues in different parts of the brain. His concept of centrencephalic seizures, arising from deep midline regions of the brain, had an important impact on the understanding of the relationship between brain structures and consciousness. Like many scientists, Penfield struggled throughout his career to demonstrate that the brain fully accounts for the mind. However, he ultimately felt that he had failed in his attempt to unify the brain and the mind. He offered a fascinating account of his experiences as a neurosurgeon and scientist observing the brains of conscious patients in his book The Mystery of the Mind.1

In a section entitled “What the Patient Thinks” in this book, Penfield summarized patients’ responses to brain stimulation as follows:2

Penfield also gave an indicative of a lack of agency in the section titled “What the Electrode Can Do’’:3

Following this description, Penfield wrote:4

He further stated:5

He thus asserted:6

Similarly, when asked whether there is a physical explanation for consciousness, atheist physicist Leonard Mlodinow, co-author of The Grand Design with Stephen Hawking, answered in the negative.7
Consciousness is not merely atoms in motion. It is not the by-product or epiphenomenon (mere side effect) of material processes, such as the biochemistry of the human brain, electrical activity of neurons, and other neural processes. This raises the question of why people lose consciousness or experience altered states of it as a result of traumatic brain injuries, anesthesia, or certain drugs. One argument for the view that consciousness is produced by the brain is that consciousness is impaired or altered when the brain is damaged. However, this fact does not rule out the possibility that the brain merely acts as a receiver and transmitter of consciousness. Consider this analogy: the radio does not produce the music it plays, yet if it is damaged, its ability to transmit the music is impaired. Similarly, the brain is an extraordinarily complex organ, but it functions only as a “signal receiving and processing system.” Consciousness is unique and cannot be reduced to mere physical processes, no matter how intricate they may be. Hence, the brain may be understood as a receiver of consciousness rather than its generator. Consider the television as another analogy. No matter how closely you examine the television’s casing, you will not find the program itself. You cannot find the presenter in a diode or transistor, nor color in any circuit or electronic component. Nothing inside the device allows you to generate the program. You can influence its transmission by turning knobs or damaging internal components, causing static (visual or audio noise) or distortion, or even rendering the device completely inoperative by unplugging it. Yet this does not prove that the program is internally generated or arises from the complexity of the device’s parts; the program persists independently. There is a correlation between the device and the program, but the device is not the program—just as the brain is not the mind. That is, the mind is something other than, and greater than, the functioning of the brain. In other words, the brain is not the origin of the mind; it is merely the receiver.
Consciousness and matter cannot be equated, because consciousness is not physical. It may have physical correlates, but in itself it is entirely nonphysical. In other words, neurotransmitters, neurons, brain chemistry, neural loops and circuits, ionic flux, electrical interference patterns, and similar processes are physical correlates of consciousness, but they are not consciousness itself. The mind is metaphysically simple—that is, it cannot be divided into parts—whereas material things can always be divided into parts.8 Roger Sperry conducted some of the most significant research on this topic in the mid-twentieth century.

Roger Sperry was a neuropsychologist and neurobiologist who received the 1981 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for his split-brain research. His work was based on a surgical procedure known as corpus callosotomy.9

Roger Sperry found that dividing the brain into two halves does not divide consciousness into two; rather, it leaves the patient with a set of perceptual impairments that are intriguing yet quite subtle. He recognized that patients whose hemispheres were functionally disconnected offered a remarkable opportunity to investigate the distinct functions of each hemisphere. Accordingly, he conducted experiments on hundreds of individuals who had undergone this split-brain surgery, and these experiments went on to become widely known.10 What Sperry observed was that these patients, for all practical purposes, functioned as completely normal individuals. Although they exhibited very subtle perceptual impairments, they were unaware of them. This remarkable subtlety is exactly why Sperry was awarded the Nobel Prize for his work—no one before him had noticed these perceptual impairments. Consequently, dividing the brain in two does not, in any meaningful sense, divide consciousness.11 The key point is that so-called split-brain patients do not possess a divided consciousness. In other words, even though their right and left hemispheres communicate little or not at all, a split brain does not produce two independent conscious experiencers within a single brain. Indeed, Sperry’s work—which shows that the brain can be divided while the mind remains unified—carries profound significance. It is also worth noting that Sperry was not a materialist; he regarded materialism as an idiotic way of understanding the brain. While he viewed the brain as a unitary entity, he was neither strictly materialist nor entirely a dualist.12 Dr. Michael Egnor—a professor and vice-chairman of Neurosurgery at Stony Brook Medical School in New York, as well as the founder and director of its neurosurgical residency program—has treated numerous patients whose hemispheres were functionally disconnected, observing the same phenomena that Sperry documented. Over the course of 35 years of clinical practice, research, and teaching, Egnor has gathered compelling evidence that the brain alone cannot fully account for the existence of consciousness. This evidence prompted him to reassess his materialist worldview, ultimately leading him to conclude that materialism is incapable of explaining the mind.13
To justify their worldview, materialist atheists insist that the brain fully accounts for the existence of consciousness. They seek to deny that humans possess free will—a point emphasized in an earlier chapter as a profoundly poisonous idea, for without free will, moral responsibility cannot exist. They claim that humans are nothing more than “meat robots,” physical organisms whose behavior is entirely determined by material processes. According to them, people are essentially chemistry sets, and their thoughts, opinions, and actions are completely dictated by the current configuration of their neurotransmitters. Their reasoning runs as follows: thoughts emerge in the mind from unconscious processes linked to the brain’s structure, and even though individuals appear to weigh these thoughts when making decisions, the outcome is predetermined by what has emerged in their minds, independent of any true choice. Materialist atheists assert that the human brain functions like a computer, producing the same output given the same initial state and inputs. Yet denying free will—and thereby moral responsibility—is one of the most fallacious and dangerous implications of the atheistic worldview, with potentially catastrophic consequences. If societies embrace the ideology promoted by this “anti-free will gang,” then all crimes could be excused, because denying free will implies that no one truly chooses their actions. Under this view, even criminal behavior becomes an inevitable consequence of the states and structures of our brains, leaving no one deserving of punishment. Indeed, rejecting free will undermines nearly everything that defines humanity, particularly human dignity, which is inseparable from its foundation—morality. Humans inherently recognize, without doubt, that they possess free will and are accountable to God. Moreover, the premise underlying all penal systems worldwide is that humans have the freedom to choose and act. Yet atheists’ commitment to materialism compels them to deny free will, since their worldview cannot account for it. The reasoning is straightforward: if there is no God, then the material world is all that exists—nothing supernatural can exist. If the physical world is all there is, every entity made of matter must be governed solely by physical laws, leaving nothing beyond matter within humans that could make genuine choices. Consequently, free will cannot exist in an atheistic framework. In contrast, the concept of a supernatural God who endows humans with a mind, consciousness, and soul aligns seamlessly with the reality of human free will. Therefore, following the evidence wherever it leads, one must conclude that human free will points to the existence of a supernatural Creator.
In summary, the logical consequence of asserting that everything in the universe consists solely of matter is that some of the most fundamental aspects of humanity are at stake. As noted above, free will is one such fundamental aspect of humanity that must be denied if materialism is true. In other words, if matter is all that truly exists, the idea that humans possess free will to guide their decisions cannot be sustained. Conversely, if humans can make genuine decisions—if they can freely decide to act or refrain from acting—then materialism is untenable because such decisions would arise from “something more than matter,” beyond any naturalistic chain of chemical cause and effect. Put simply, if there is “something” within the human being that freely chooses this or rejects that, then the materialist conception of the universe is fundamentally flawed. Therefore, atheism is false because humans have free will and atheism entails that they do not. Without question, atheism cannot fully understand or explain the phenomenon of “Man,” and a gray, jelly-like mass of tissue in the head cannot account for the emergence of something as complex as consciousness. Once again, the brain does not generate consciousness; it merely receives it. Consciousness lies beyond the scope of science because it is empirically unobservable and cannot be measured or quantified objectively. Consequently, science as we know it is incapable of explaining consciousness. Neuroscience itself points to the immaterial nature of consciousness: epilepsy surgery has shown that even when the brain is split in half, the higher faculties of the mind remain intact, and individuals can live normal lives with their brains split or with large portions missing. Hence, in addressing the question of consciousness, materialism has indeed encountered an impasse.
Notes and References
- 1
Wilder Penfield, Mystery of the Mind: A Critical Study of Consciousness and the Human Brain, (Princeton, U.S.: Princeton University Press, 1978).
- 2
Ibid., p. 76.
- 3
Ibid., pp. 76–77.
- 4
Ibid., pp. 77–78.
- 5
Ibid.
- 6
Ibid., p. 109.
- 7
“The Consciousness Crisis in Materialism,” YouTube, uploaded by DA3WA 1412, 21 Aug. 2015, https://youtu.be/S5OXzP-5KMs.
- 8
“Michael Egnor Interview | Problems for Materialism and Problems from Materialism,” YouTube, uploaded by Theology Unleashed, 23 Jul. 2021, https://www.youtube.com/live/qVeKN5r-mT8?feature=shared, [55:57-56:43].
- 9
Universiteit van Amsterdam (UVA), “Split Brain does not Lead to Split Consciousness,” Science Daily, 25 Jan. 2017, https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2017/01/170125093823.htm.
- 10
“Michael Egnor Interview | Problems for Materialism and Problems from Materialism,” YouTube, uploaded by Theology Unleashed, 23 Jul. 2021, https://www.youtube.com/live/qVeKN5r-mT8?feature=shared, [59:19-59:42].
- 11
Ibid., [1:01:50-1:02:33].
- 12
Ibid., [1:02:34-1:02:55].
- 13
Ibid., [4:43-4:46].